Benny Scarpetta’s Pizza, located at 1019 Main Street in Lynchburg, Virginia, opened its doors in 2016, quickly establishing itself as a popular destination within the downtown area. The establishment is recognized for its notably large, New York-style pizza slices, serving a 28-inch pie that can be ordered by the slice or as a whole. Beyond its signature pizza, Benny Scarpetta’s offers an engaging atmosphere that includes a classic arcade featuring a selection of pinball machines, as well as classic video games such as Centipede and Ms. Pac-Man.
The Lynchburg location was reportedly established after a local boy, Cooper Cook, wrote to the owners of the Benny’s chain, requesting a pizza establishment in his hometown. Occupying the historic “old Famous building,” a site with a nearly century-long commercial history on Main Street, Benny Scarpetta’s contributes to the ongoing revitalization of Downtown Lynchburg. It has become a favored spot for both residents and college students, offering a casual, late-night dining experience and even a “Benny’s Challenge” for those daring to consume an entire 28-inch pizza.
